This forum has been archived. All content is frozen. Please use KDE Discuss instead.

Collection Browser sorting

Tags: None
(comma "," separated)
Xe.Qon
Karma
0

Collection Browser sorting

Sat Oct 30, 2004 12:17 am
This is a suggestion I had for the 1.1 beta, but I suggested it after the feature freeze. So now, I'm finally getting around to resuggesting it, as I think it's a small thing that could be very useful.

An option to ignore certain words in collection browser sorting would be nice. For example, I don't care about the words "The" or "A" at the beginning of an albums' name; I would much rather the album be sorted by the second word in these cases, as that word is more meaningful to me. (E.g., I would rather that "The Beatles" be listed near "Bob Dylan", rather than "Ted Leo and the Pharmacists".) I would still want the words displayed, of course (otherwise I would just rewrite the artist tag as "Beatles", in this case.)

This could be internationalized, as well -- German-speakers presumably don't care about a "Das" starting a title, nor do French-speakers likely care about "Le" or "L'".

Hope this makes sense. Thanks for your great work on Amarok!
muesli
KDE Developer
Posts
230
Karma
0

Re:Collection Browser sorting

Sun Oct 31, 2004 8:33 pm
i'd rather suggest retagging your files properly....

the suggested method is a PAIN in the A** (sorry). in german it would then be "der / die / das", in french "le / la" etc. etc. with 50 languages around, it would take ages to check all the possibilites.

besides: it sucks on the ipod, and i hate it. i always look at the wrong place to find the artist. (damn you, why is "The Beatles" at the top of my list, even though it starts with a 'T').

...muesli
User avatar
Max Howell
Alumni
Posts
195
Karma
0

Re:Collection Browser sorting

Mon Nov 01, 2004 11:20 am
An option in the config dialog:

Prefixes to ignore:

INPUT_BOX

I'd stick 'the' in there, maybe even der,die and das. The performance implications would be fine, muesli, should I try?
User avatar
eean
KDE Developer
Posts
1016
Karma
0
OS

Re:Collection Browser sorting

Mon Nov 01, 2004 1:02 pm
yea, I agree trying to have it be internationalized would be stupid, especially since plenty of people have more the one language in their album titles.

I generally remember whether or not there is a 'the' and usually just use the filter at the top regardless.


Amarok Developer
Xe.Qon
Karma
0

Re:Collection Browser sorting

Mon Nov 01, 2004 1:48 pm
mxcl's suggestion sounds good to me, since that seems to be the most flexible way to allow for everybody's preferences without adding (I agree) unnecessarily messy internationalization.

As for why I would want it that way, it's purely aesthetic... I want to see the full name of a band (which can include a "the"), but I want them sorted by the first "important" word, much as I would sort my bookshelf. Otherwise I end up with half of my bands showing up in the T section, which I just don't like the looks of. Obviously there are other ways to get around this, but none that I like as much.

Thanks for the feedback and discussion; it's nice to hear other peoples' opinions and get input from the developers.


Bookmarks



Who is online

Registered users: Bing [Bot], gfielding, Google [Bot], Sogou [Bot]