Reply to topic

Frame accurate editing and rendering

Registered Member

I'm trying to find the most suitable codecs for frame accurate editing.

I've tried editing my original MPEG2 (interframe encoded) files but can't seek accurately in the timeline. I know video files with GOP structures can be difficult to edit, so enabled the proxy option - but that didn't help.

Looking at the proxy cache dir, mediainfo says that the files aren't i-frame only. Trying to use different proxy encoding settings has no effect (files are always generated as MPEG2 .ts with a GOP structure). Not sure if this is part of the problem?

Converting src files to DV format before importing improves accuracy - but the encoded output is still consistently one frame out compared to the timeline preview. I created a stopwatch video and can see in the timeline the first frame of the clip is repeated twice - which doesn't happen in the rendered output (H.264 in .mp4 container).

Does anyone have any suggestions?


Reply to topic


Who is online

Registered users: andreas_k, Baidu [Spider], Bing [Bot], Exabot [Bot], Google [Bot], jeromerobert, La Ninje, leesmith, Majestic-12 [Bot], mgallien, pinnerite, SecretCode, smankowski, subdiff, the_mouse, threerss, victorhck, YaCy [Bot], Yahoo [Bot]